Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Events Cause Mariners To Lose To Rangers

The local recruiting disconnect

A couple of weeks ago Steve and Mason Kelley of the Seattle Times started talking about a possible disconnect the Washington football coaching staff was having with local coaches and recruits.

The message was that local talent was being ignored in some cases in favor of California talent and it was rubbing a number of coaches and recruits the wrong way.

This took most of us by surprise because we all thought that Sark and his staff were pretty popular in the state of Washington. On the surface the staff seemed to be comprised of a bunch of humble hard working types who really cared about the kids in their program.

As far as local recruiting goes Sark and Holt were part of a staff at USC under Pete Carrol which was legendary in how they handled recruiting in the LA area. They outworked everybody even though they were USC and could just pick and choose from he best local talent available.

When Sark took over at Washington it was assumed that his staff would approach things the same way that Carroll did at USC. The first thing Sark did which I was thought was brilliant was divide the state of Washington up evenly among all the coaches on his staff.

I thought it was a great idea because it allowed all the coaches in the state the opportunity to get to know the entire staff. Local blue chips such as Desmond Trufant, Bishop Sankey, Austin Seferian-Jenkins, Kasen Williams, Sione Potoae, Taniela Tupuo, and Danny Shelton confirmed the belief that things were headed in the right direction by electing to stay home and play at Washington.

To me this was all a solid sign that the coaches were putting up a solid fence around the state and that the program coming off an impressive 19-6 win over Nebraska in the Holiday Bowl was about to reap a local bonanza of blue chip talent for the 2012 recruiting class.

Not so fast as Lee Corso is so fond of saying. I have been following recruiting for approximately thirty five years and I have never seen a single local recruiting season like this. Sure even DJ lost a local kid to Notre Dame, BYU, and Stanford once in a while but losing the top 4-5 players in the state in a single year is pretty much unheard of.

So what do local recruits think of Washington these days?

KeiVarae Russell (Mariner)...."First of all, my mom doesn't like U-Dub at all, she told me she doesn't want me to go there and that was a big influence in my life. My mom doesn't want me to go to this school, I won't feel comfortable going to a school my mom doesn't want me to go to. But when Notre Dame came for my in-home visit she said, ‘That's the spot where I want you to go."

Josh Garnett (Puyallup)..."I would have cut them a long time ago as a program if I lived in California or Chicago. But since I was from here I felt like it was my duty a little bit to keep them on the list."

Walker Williams (Tacoma Baptist)..."Those UW fans on the blogs and everything are ridiculas. 1st I'm garbage and they don't need me, then josh is weak cause he's not goin either, not u aren't a good player cause u ain't goin to UW. I wonder if they realize how much bein jerks to UW recruits who decide not to go there hurts washingtons recruitment. I don't think they realize that all the in state guys know each other and lots of them are friends. They can dig their own graves tho!"

Zach Banner (Lakes)..."I have to give it a 12 - I saw what it was like to be a U-Dub Husky. I think that's the one thing I had never seen before, never got the full feeling. For 48 hours, you're part of the team; you can relate to everybody and talk with everybody and joke around. It was a good experience.

Cedric Dozier (Lakes)..."That was my last visit (California)," said Dozier. "I’m through."

So obviously the Kelly's are correct. There is something wrong with current perception of the Washington football program (Can't blame this one on Tyrone) and Sark needs to get it fixed. Corrective action started yesterday when he fired three coaches from his defensive staff. However that will not salvage the 2012 recruiting class.

These are the type of losses that can be felt for years down the line and derail coaching careers. Sark is at a crossroads and he needs to make the right choices going forward to regain momentum and keep the program headed in the right direction.

Comment 148 comments  |  1 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

It appears this perception is not just with local kids. Of all the visits we have had from recruits who had not previously committed how many have committed after the visit not many. I see a recent visitor OL Poutasi just committed to Utah.

We really need to close big to save this class. Listening to Dawgman yesterday it sounds like they are 50 – 50 if Banner will commit to the UW. We need coaches who can teach and also recruit and a big closer.

by lorenzothedog on Jan 1, 2012 11:41 AM PST reply actions  

F*** You Seattle Tmes Blog Commenters

Walker Williams (Tacoma Baptist)…“Those UW fans on the blogs and everything are ridiculas. 1st I’m garbage and they don’t need me, then josh is weak cause he’s not goin either, not u aren’t a good player cause u ain’t goin to UW. I wonder if they realize how much bein jerks to UW recruits who decide not to go there hurts washingtons recruitment. I don’t think they realize that all the in state guys know each other and lots of them are friends. They can dig their own graves tho!”

Roast Duck is a delicacy.

by PurpleHeart on Jan 1, 2012 11:47 AM PST reply actions  

I'm sure if Walker Williams or the others

bothered to look at most other schools or local newspaper blogs as often as they do for their own local area, they would see that there are trolls and punks out there on all the schools blogs (see UCLA, Texas, Notre Dame), but that doesn’t make it right. That’s the reason I will only look at comments on this blog. At least they are mostly civilized when it comes to recruits.

I’m not sure why KV’s mom hates UW so much, but maybe she’s Catholic or something.

I’m not sure what Sark can do about the external stuff, but hopefully he can change the perception that he likes the LA kids better than the in-state kids, because I don’t believe it to be true. He is just trying to get the best kids possible to come to UW.

"The same thing that will make you laugh will make you cry." Ray Lewis

by Carne Guisada on Jan 1, 2012 2:51 PM PST up reply actions  

I'm sorry but

Walker Williams is an idiot if he let message board readers sway his decision. First of all that makes little sense because most people would not complain until after he committed to the school. Once he did that what did he expect? People to say “oh congrats for you on going to Wisconsin”? The people who are bashing this kid are not Badger fans… they are fans of the school you did not choose? Why would he be looking on a school he did not choose to go to’s page and why would he care what they think?

What does he expect to happen? Fans of another school to praise him for not choosing their school? Does he expect Michigan fans to applaud him if he pancakes a Michigan player? Please….

Here is the truth… Wisconsin fans will treat you well because YOU CHOSE TO GO THEIR. Husky fans will not because you chose to go some where else. Simple as that. If you lived and grew up in Wisconsin and chose to come to UW over the home school believe me… those fans would have been just as pissed.

This is a cop out answer to use… Don’t blame me.. blame the fans on message boards. Please. Hope you are reading this Walker Williams. Husky fans are no different than any other fan base who lose out on a in state guy.

Here is my pc respose. “Hope you have the best career of all time in Wisconsin and that you become an all american. You will always be welcome back and treated like a husky even though you decided to go somewhere else” Sincerely Husky Nation

by DAWGFAN87 on Jan 1, 2012 2:53 PM PST up reply actions  

Peer influence
First of all that makes little sense because most people would not complain until after he committed to the school. Once he did that what did he expect? People to say "oh congrats for you on going to Wisconsin"?

Williams isn’t saying his decision was made by people dissing him. He’s making a general statement about how high school kids think. They are influenced much more by their peers than we care to realize. So, he gets trashed for not going to UW and next year, when we’re trying to recruit his friends, he’ll be in their ear saying “F’ UW. Their fans said X, Y, and Z about me after I turned them down.” And that will be something Sark and company will have to contend with. You don’t have to throw him a parade for choosing Wisconsin, but you can be polite.

I know this seems completely irrational to an adult. As an adult, you can recognize that it’s a small minority of the fans that are trashing him; that it’s an expression of disappointment, not an indictment of his true talents; and that choosing a program to play for should not be based on emotion, but on the potential for that program to take you to the next level. Reality check. These recruits, however good they are at football, are still high school kids.

by bdubzz on Jan 1, 2012 6:54 PM PST up reply actions  

exactly

I really don’t see how it’s so hard for adults to take the high road and avoid trashing recruits that reject the UW. Nobody is saying we have to praise them, but is it too much to ask to not trash them?

I may not like how Russell handled his announcement – I think it was a slap in the face of the UW (whether intentional or not), but I’m not going to say I didn’t want him to be a Husky and that I don’t think he’s a good prospect.

These kids – and their families and friends – read the various boards. And they talk to fellow prospects, both in the current class and in future classes. It would be in our best interests as fans of Husky football to not make it any harder for the coaching staff in their task of recruiting.

by kirkd on Jan 1, 2012 7:19 PM PST up reply actions  

You're operating under the premise

I really don’t see how it’s so hard for adults to take the high road

That these are adults. Oh sure, they may be in their 30’s, 40’s and 50’s, but any person trashing a PSA on the web is clearly demonstrating that they have a lot of growing up to do. And that my friend, is the greater tragedy.

by TualatinDawg on Jan 1, 2012 7:40 PM PST up reply actions  

Many of them are in their early 20s

And many of them believe they are fighting against a NW sports culture that is content with being the fat girl at the prom.

I miss *REAL* Four Loko

by B-Lot tailgater on Jan 3, 2012 9:55 AM PST up reply actions  

it's not just them...

…it’s posters at various Husky related websites. I tend to think the comments here are pretty even-handed, but other forums are much less so.

by kirkd on Jan 1, 2012 7:14 PM PST up reply actions  

"Death Of The Newpaper" ...(A National Disgrace...)

But truthfully…it is an idiot-fest over there! “Just Say No”

by gliderdawg on Jan 1, 2012 8:20 PM PST up reply actions  

Williams' comment takes me straight back to Baltergeist' comments last month.
But the real problem with the doom and gloomers I have right now is recruiting. Not only are people calling this class a disappointment before it’s anywhere close to being finished, but, particularly here, people are writing off and insulting the kids that do commit because they don’t have a 5 star rating. You in particular make me embarrassed to be a Husky. If the 5 star kids see that, you think they’re gonna want to come here? I know better, and you should too. Even if we don’t get our top targets and we do end up with a bunch of 2 star commits, we have to welcome these kids to the Husky family. You can absolutely be disappointed, but to tear down the kids who do play here because of it is absolutely disgusting.

by Carl Shinyama on Jan 1, 2012 11:58 AM PST reply actions   1 recs

If by any chance Williams' reads this:

There are those of us like myself who REALLY, REALLY, REALLY wanted you to choose UW!

by Carl Shinyama on Jan 1, 2012 12:00 PM PST reply actions  

You would be surprised

You would be very surprised about who reads this blog every day.

UW Dawg Pound - SBN Seattle

by John Berkowitz on Jan 1, 2012 1:29 PM PST up reply actions  

Hopefully the kids are smart enough to know that the negative posters on blogs represent less than 1% of the fans. There are jerks in every fan base not just UW’s.

by Snostrebla on Jan 1, 2012 2:05 PM PST up reply actions  

Exactly.

"Winning isn't everything, it's the only thing."
"Legends are made on the shores of Lake Washington"

by Lear Pilot on Jan 1, 2012 2:17 PM PST up reply actions  

I guess I'm a much different person than Keivarae Russell

But if I was a blue chip football player at his age, with a generous number of colleges offering me a scholarship, I make the decision where I want to go to college, not my mom, regardless of whether or not she wants me to go to whichever school I chose to go to.

That said, I really wish him the best!

by Carl Shinyama on Jan 1, 2012 12:06 PM PST reply actions  

I think I would be a little more classy on the way out the door...

I think Mr Russell and his mom burned some bridges…good luck…you are going to need it.

UW Dawg Pound - SBN Seattle

by John Berkowitz on Jan 1, 2012 1:30 PM PST up reply actions  

Totally agree John...

Brian Kelly’s offense isn’t exactly setting school records. I couldn’t stay awake through his offensive jugernaut at the champ sports bowl…. I guess coaching is a little different when you’re playing inferior opponents in the Big Least at Cincinatti.

by BC Dawg on Jan 1, 2012 1:39 PM PST up reply actions  

Kelly won't get his contract renewed at Notre Dame

It has nothing to do with coaching either…he just isn’t a good fit and the way he handled the death of the kid who was killed filming football was inexcusable…he and the AD should have been fired immediately…that being said…he has no grace period at ND.

UW Dawg Pound - SBN Seattle

by John Berkowitz on Jan 1, 2012 2:03 PM PST up reply actions  

Wow...just wow.

I forgot about that terrible accident! You’re right…he basically pushed that kid! Jerk…No wonder I can’t stand that guy.

by gliderdawg on Jan 1, 2012 7:42 PM PST up reply actions  

I was shocked he wasn't fired for that.

All the information necessary to prevent that accident was right in front of him and he chose to ignore it.

by JoeinFW on Jan 1, 2012 7:48 PM PST up reply actions  

Kelly is a worthless prick

…easy for me to say since the kid is from our neighborhood in suburban Chicago…just a really selfish prick…

UW Dawg Pound - SBN Seattle

by John Berkowitz on Jan 1, 2012 8:32 PM PST up reply actions  

I didn't realize it was someone you knew

Not to rehash the past but sorry to hear that. The fact he lasted through that event was shocking.

Notre Dame fans need to start tempering expectations. Catholic schools are not the pipe line they used to be. For instance, Philadelphia had one of the biggest, if not the biggest, Catholic school systems in the country. They had their own high school football league and championship until recently when they joined the rest of the state. They are shutting down schools left and right out here because enrollment is no where near what it used to be. Even with a strong catholic league presense, I couldn’t tell you the last kid that chose ND from Philly…and there is a TON of talent in this area. A big reason Penn State has struggled lately was because of Joe Paternos lack of recruitment in that area.

OK, sorry, rants and off topic post are over…

by bigdave967 on Jan 2, 2012 7:08 AM PST up reply actions  

Why do I get the feeling they are Catholic?

Any good catholic mom would want her son to go to Notre Dame. It’s really too bad that so many young kids are letting their parents make the decision for them. I’m all for parents guiding their kids, but I’ve seen way too many parents make their kids live the life they wanted, but can’t have. If you don’t do what YOU are happy doing and let others control your decisions, you are going to live a miserable life.

"Winning isn't everything, it's the only thing."
"Legends are made on the shores of Lake Washington"

by Lear Pilot on Jan 1, 2012 2:22 PM PST up reply actions  

Why does she hate UW?

That is probably the silliest thing that I have ever heard.

UW Dawg Pound - SBN Seattle

by John Berkowitz on Jan 1, 2012 2:26 PM PST up reply actions  

Makes ZERO sense to me.

"Winning isn't everything, it's the only thing."
"Legends are made on the shores of Lake Washington"

by Lear Pilot on Jan 1, 2012 2:27 PM PST up reply actions  

Agreed...

I think this year’s group of in-state 4 and 5-stars were an anomaly, for the most part. Lots of silly excuses for not respecting and considering a fine home-town university with a top-flite head coach and a building football program. Sayanora to all…and hope you enjoy Berserkly, Indiana, SoCal, suburban Detroit and/or Oklahoma. I’m betting a year from now most of you will regret not only the choice you made but (for some) the bridges you burned with your neighbors and local fans.

by Saltherring on Jan 2, 2012 7:21 AM PST up reply actions  

Perhaps, perhaps not.

I happen to think that recruits should be making their decision based on which school that they want to go to, not by their mom or dad.

by Carl Shinyama on Jan 2, 2012 10:53 AM PST up reply actions  

there's no question about Polk

Polk wanted to go to USC and had committed there; it was at the insistence of his mom that he reconsider and go to Washington, because she felt very strongly about Ty Willingham.

by kirkd on Jan 2, 2012 12:27 PM PST up reply actions  

She also felt very strongly about playing time which UW had a lot to give Chris. At USC he would have been told to get in line.

by Snostrebla on Jan 2, 2012 7:56 PM PST up reply actions  

Over reacting just a bit

I think this year is different. We have gotten some local kids and if you made me pick I would take Lindquist every time. Sure big local linemen would be great but we have such a California influence on this team and still on the board. As far as fixing this mythical local riff in local kids is almost like a witch hunt. Kids leave California like it’s a norm kids leave here and it’s a how dare they. You are either a dog or you’re not . if you think this class is going to make or break sark you are right but that is every year, this one has a ways to go. If you don’t think that Alamo bowl had good things in it for sark you are craze. Bryce Treggs had Keith price for Heisman next year on his twitter, with plenty of other kids with the same to say. I think husky fans need to drop the complex problem DJ won for years with 3 star kids just like kieth price was a 3 star and broke a few school records

by Go Dawgs on Jan 1, 2012 12:08 PM PST reply actions  

This is a huge over reaction

Your comments are right on. Keith Price is from California, not Washington. A few in state guys leaving is not the end of the world. Sark has done a great job with in state recruiting. You can’t win them all every year.

by datboyeddiep on Jan 1, 2012 2:16 PM PST up reply actions  

Take football out of it

Think of it this way. Lets say that you take the top 10 scholars out of the state of Washington for 2011. They are in the middle of applying to schools but really they have the option of going to any school in the county (Basically same situation as top football recruits). Last year for various reasons all those top scholars chose to go to The University of Washington over other ivy league schools. This year the top scholars one chose to go to Yale, one Harvard, one Stanford because they wanted to live some where else for 4 years and experience another place. They also thought the school fit was better than UW.

To me recruiting is this simple. People choose to go out of state for college all the time for various reasons. Last year it just happened that all the best football players in state also WANTED to go to UW. This year the top players want to go out of state.. To me it is that simple. No matter what UW did it did not matter because they wanted to go some where else. If we were losing recruits to Oregon Oregon St or Washington state I would be concerned. But that fact of the matter is that every single top recruit is leaving the NW. Maybe it is as simple as they wanted to go off on their own, play at a top school and experience college some where else.

If this was not football but just scholars it would make sense. My suggestion don’t think about losing out on recruits because some just want to get away.

by DAWGFAN87 on Jan 1, 2012 3:04 PM PST up reply actions  

Exactly!!

As somebody who is adept at statistics, it is obvious that the sample size is too small to make any judgment on Sark’s ability to “erect the fence.” Even if you flip a fair coin repeatedly, there are times when it will come up 6,7,8 heads in a row. This doesn’t mean that the coin is biased.

Apart from Russell’s mom saying that she “hates UW” the decisions come down to young men deciding for themselves where to spend the next four years of their lives. For some—like Garnett—getting away from where they grew up is the number one priority. It just so happens that a few of these recruits happened to come down the pipe at the same time.

If the best talent in WA leaves the state year-after-year, then we’ll have something to worry about.

by lowermainlanddawg on Jan 1, 2012 8:31 PM PST up reply actions  

still have a month

a lot can happen in the next 30 days or so. Sark wants to win and take the program to the next level. The firing displayed this. You want football players who want to be part of a program. It will be interesting to see what happens to Oregon. Might be able to capture some of their talent when the NCAA finally sanctions them.

by Lets Go on Jan 1, 2012 12:16 PM PST reply actions  

I think this is a bit premature

It’s not good to lose all these guys in one year, but then again it’s just that: one year. And it’s one year removed from running the table on blue chips. If it were a trend then it’d would be time to sound the alarm, but at this point it’s just one year.

And on Walker Williams, well, every football school has commenters and messageboards that give the rational fans a bad name. However, MOST recruits are smart enough to know that theyre the vocal minority.

by thecassino on Jan 1, 2012 12:27 PM PST reply actions  

Walker

It doesn’t really seem like spelling, punctuation, and grammar are his strong suit.

UW Dawg Pound - SBN Seattle

by John Berkowitz on Jan 1, 2012 12:41 PM PST up reply actions  

Please don't insult the house plant

It is an innocent bystander.

Walker Williams is the best Off. Linemen ever! (just in case he is reading this)

by bigdave967 on Jan 2, 2012 7:10 AM PST up reply actions  

For that reason....

I’m surprised he didn’t choose Oregon….

by Saltherring on Jan 2, 2012 7:23 AM PST up reply actions  

Has Williams ever seen blog comments for other teams?

Like, if a kid from the South picks Auburn over Bama? We’renothing compared to them.

by huskies2010 on Jan 1, 2012 1:05 PM PST reply actions  

Williams

My feeling has always been that the UW coaches really made a huge mistake by not going after Williams early and hard. I think that really offended him and he retaliated by never giving UW a decent shot.

UW Dawg Pound - SBN Seattle

by John Berkowitz on Jan 1, 2012 1:34 PM PST up reply actions  

Yep, I hope Walker Williams

remembers his words as he sloshes through those Wisconsin winters…or thinks about coming “home” for Christmas.

The decisions you make as an 18-year old DO IMPACT the rest of your life. Remember that when things don’t work out so well and the people in your new “home” suddenly forget how much they wanted you two years ago. How will the “home” folks remember you, Walker?

by Saltherring on Jan 2, 2012 7:34 AM PST up reply actions  

No "low road" intended,

simply supplying some much needed wisdom to a kid who certainly needs it, considering the tone of his parting remarks.

by Saltherring on Jan 2, 2012 3:09 PM PST up reply actions  

This is what you call "wisdom?"

It sounds like sour grapes

Damn, my eyeball tastes good.
@chrislandon

by Gekko Mojo on Jan 2, 2012 6:44 PM PST up reply actions  

we offered him pretty early John

We offered him in late May, about 45 days after Wisconsin & Oregon St. Should Sark have offered him earlier? Maybe, but he was still offered quite early. And let’s be honest – while he’s a good prospect, he’s not (at the moment) as coveted a prospect as Garnett & Banner.

Now, I have no idea how hard Sark recruited him after offering him, and how much love he was getting from the staff before the official offer was extended – maybe Sark blew it in that regard.

by kirkd on Jan 1, 2012 3:53 PM PST up reply actions  

true. Ever try listening to Finebaum?

If recruits cared about the idiot minority, then Bama would never get another recruit. Their fanbase is even slightly worse than, well, you know who.

Damn, my eyeball tastes good.
@chrislandon

by Gekko Mojo on Jan 2, 2012 7:10 AM PST up reply actions  

Walker Williams

I cannot fault an offensive linemen for wanting to play up front for Wisconsin. They put offensive linemen in the league every year and they obviously produce top talent. What I do fault him for is his lack of understanding how message boards work.

Side Note- I think Pitt made a great hire by taking Chryst, Wisconsins Off. Coordinator. Pitt is a blue collar area with lots of great linemen and running backs at their disposal. HUGE upgrade over Graham in my opinion.

by bigdave967 on Jan 1, 2012 1:55 PM PST reply actions  

Scott and Josh Garnett are class acts

I think he did a great job advising his son during his recruitment. He made it very clear to Josh that the UW he went to and won a national championship at (84) was not the same school or program today.

I am hearing that Scott would have preferred that Josh stay home but wanted the decision to be 100% his. I really wish Josh had picked UW because he is a great kid and a class act.

UW Dawg Pound - SBN Seattle

by John Berkowitz on Jan 1, 2012 1:59 PM PST reply actions  

If we could get a guy like Josh to come to UW it would go a long way in helping bring the Dawgs back to the type of team Scott played for.

by Snostrebla on Jan 1, 2012 2:12 PM PST up reply actions  

Scott was from a big time recruit from California

He is pretty darn savvy about the entire process.

UW Dawg Pound - SBN Seattle

by John Berkowitz on Jan 1, 2012 2:16 PM PST up reply actions  

Maybe it's just me . . .

I don’t know the family, and only those VERY close to the family would know, but it seems like it could be one of the following scenarios:

1 – Elway Syndrome: Kid doesn’t love it like dad does. John Elway’s kid just didn’t have the love for football like dad, nothing wrong with that, just unfortunate that it took until college for everybody to realize it.

2 – Marinovich Syndrome: Parent pushes way to hard to prove something, or to live vicariously through their child. Child gets too much of it and gets burned out.

Could be that Josh just wants to get out of dad’s shadow. Like I said, I don’t know, just wild assumptions from an outsiders point of view.

"Winning isn't everything, it's the only thing."
"Legends are made on the shores of Lake Washington"

by Lear Pilot on Jan 1, 2012 2:52 PM PST up reply actions  

Marovich syndrome

You give the kid the ball and he never gives it back and keeps shooting it.

UW Dawg Pound - SBN Seattle

by John Berkowitz on Jan 2, 2012 5:26 AM PST up reply actions  

people have a distorted view of the Todd Marinovich story

You should all watch the ESPN “30 on 30” feature on Todd Marinovich. It is a misconception to say that Marv pushed Todd into football; Todd loved it. Todd’s issues were not really about him being pressured into playing football – they stemmed from a variety of other reasons.

by kirkd on Jan 2, 2012 12:29 PM PST up reply actions  

elways kid

He just wasn’t very good

by CODawg on Jan 2, 2012 7:33 AM PST up reply actions  

Those are great points...and why it hurts so bad to lose him!

Top quality with class! He will succeed wherever..but we all just wish it was in a brand new stadium of purple and gold…Ouch!

by gliderdawg on Jan 1, 2012 7:49 PM PST up reply actions  

I think we have to be careful with the conclusions we draw on in-state recruiting

Obviously something is amiss with 4 key guys heading elsewhere. But even if the Kelly’s are correct, we don’t have the details of who and what they were referring to. It could well be whispers at Bellevue since we have not yet offered Hasty and only recently Eldrenkamp. Perhaps it’s down at Lakes since we did not offer Webb and Manea. You could make the case that the staff has been targeting California players ahead of each of these guys. Maybe it’s the pressure tactic they used on Caleb Smith. Whatever the issue is – and perception is most likely the issue more than actual behavior (just my guess).

Let’s look a the 4 that are going elsewhere:

Russell – we offered early and clearly wanted him bringing him in for a Dec visit, his coach said the staff did a great classly job recruiting him (does that sound like an unhappy coach?); I think we need to know why his mom dislikes UW, this could have absolutely nothing to do with the coaches, that seems more logical than anything; I just wish he would have eliminated us earlier if his mom never was going to let him go to UW

Garnett – obviously we offered him a long time ago and I cannot for one minute think that the staff let up on him, that just doesn’t make any sense; I recall the Dawgman guys even a few years ago after he first go offered by UCLA saying he was already looking out of state; seems we were all just hopeful but never was realistic for whatever reason, and we don’t know if this has anything to do with the coaches and their approach/effort/focus on Garnett (that we’ve heard)

Dozier – we also offered him very early and clearly wanted him, he goes to a school that does well feeding UW; he wants to be a WR and we said CB which is probably what will happen to him at Cal anyway; for some reason he very early targeted Cal and it seems for personal reasons he was simply looking to leave; again I’ve yet to see any hint he was unhappy with the approach or effort of the staff (unless the lack of offers for the other Lakes guys played some factor we haven’t heard about)

Williams – this is the recruit that could be the center of the issues; we didn’t offer him super early, but neither did we wait until late in the game; we know he is close with Garnett, Banner, and seeing the posts also Russell to a degree; he picked Wisc long before any of this instate recruiting churn came up; perhaps as JB said, he wasn’t treated with the same level of emphasis as Garnett and Banner but how could he really be surprised by that; maybe he felt he was only being offered to entice the other two guys; either way, looks like we didn’t push hard early and he didn’t like it; and of anyone is he the one putting bugs in Russell and other’s ears? If so, was it enough to influence the decisions? When you look at this offer sheet it’s commensurate with his 3 star ranking and to some degree it’s interesting that Wisc found him and offered early – they don’t typically come out this way and are by far the best offer he got, though they didn’t offer the other two – they just saw something in him and probably saw him as a good developmental prospect.

When we look at the rest of the instate class, this rumor hasn’t hurt w/ Lindquist, English, Rector, Dean, etc. At the end of the day, we just don’t know what this rumor/issue really is, where it’s coming from and how it really has impacting things in reality. This could have nothing to do with why we have swung and missed on these big names this year. This also doesn’t mean Sark and the new staff don’t have some work to do to get a better sales pitch going and build better relationships with HS coaches. It also makes you wonder if Cozz is the type of recruiter and coach that we need since he could be the only common thread between Williams, Garnett and Banner. He seems to have had some reputational problems during his first stint at UW. Anything to this JB that we should be hoping Sark looks to address after fixing the D staff?

by WoodyH on Jan 1, 2012 2:16 PM PST reply actions   1 recs

Cozzetto

He is a solid old school coach who knows how to get after it. I think his players get better with each rep but I wouldn’t describe him as being a charismatic recruiter. I would have preferred someone like Jim Michaelczik….but I wasn’t bummed out when Cozzetto was hired after Jim reconsidered.

UW Dawg Pound - SBN Seattle

by John Berkowitz on Jan 1, 2012 2:25 PM PST up reply actions  

So can we start removing posts that speak negatively about PSA's?

I don’t understand why Russell’s mom would dislike UW so much but I sincerely hope it’s not a legitimate reason that would cause other parents to be concerned about where their kids go to college.

As for what Williams said… I’d tell him to think about the age/occupation of most of the people posting things like that and to take into account how many of them actually went to the University of Washington. Every school has its bad apples but most graduates of UW have nothing but good things to say about the school and their time there. Every other school in the country has the same crap being posted on their blogs when players commit elsewhere and of course if you live in the state you’re going to hear a lot more crap because immature people will see it as a betrayal.

Oh and if you’re a recruit: DO NOT READ DAWGMAN FORUMS OR SEATTLE TIMES BLOG COMMENTS. It can be severely hazardous to your health.

by JoeinFW on Jan 1, 2012 2:30 PM PST reply actions  

I won't read any comments ANY where but here.

It’s a complete and utter waste of time.

"Winning isn't everything, it's the only thing."
"Legends are made on the shores of Lake Washington"

by Lear Pilot on Jan 1, 2012 2:40 PM PST up reply actions  

I like your idea

I’m all for deleting negative comments about recruits. I’m all for honest observations, or honest critiques, but anything that falls into recruit bashing should be deleted.

That being said, it does sound like Williams has a chip on his shoulder caused by not getting enough love from the UW staff.

"Winning isn't everything, it's the only thing."
"Legends are made on the shores of Lake Washington"

by Lear Pilot on Jan 1, 2012 2:55 PM PST up reply actions  

Troll Free Zone

I try to keep this a troll free zone…once they get a foothold it ruins it for everybody.

UW Dawg Pound - SBN Seattle

by John Berkowitz on Jan 2, 2012 5:28 AM PST up reply actions  

Maybe

If we had more basketball coverage I would do the same but I am active on Percy Allen’s blog as well to get my fix for basketball as uwdawgpound doesn’t have as much basketball coverage as I crave.

Roast Duck is a delicacy.

by PurpleHeart on Jan 1, 2012 5:04 PM PST up reply actions  

Another thing on Williams...

Badmouthing the major university in your home state is a really REALLY bad idea… Burning bridges in your hometown/state isn’t how you want to start your college career regardless of where you’re going. I wish this kid the best of luck in Wisconsin but I hope he realizes if he screws up there their fans will let him have it on their blogs just as badly as anywhere else.

by JoeinFW on Jan 1, 2012 3:18 PM PST up reply actions  

Good advice, but give him time, he's young.

I admit that when I was young and stupid, I was indeed young and stupid.

by HuskyInExile on Jan 1, 2012 11:59 PM PST up reply actions  

I'm pretty torn on this subject.

It definitely is concerning that we have lost 4 of the top in state recruits. How is it that 4 guys are so set on staying away from the UW? It leads to the belief that their is a rift, but it’s hard to come to a solid conclusion when you think about how well we did in state last year.

Keeping Shelton, ASJ, Williams, and Sankey in state was HUGE. They are, BY FAR, the top recruits from last years class. Without the WA kids, last years class would have made ZERO contributions to the 2011 team. They are going to be the leaders, the heart and soul of the program for the next few years. I find it shocking that the current in state high school class doesn’t see how well these guys are doing and how bright their future would be if they stayed home and played at the UW.

Shelton, ASJ, Williams and Sankey will forever be held in the highest regard throughout the state of Washington. They are the future of the program, the leaders who will return us to the top of the conference. Shoot, they could become local hero’s/legends by the time their UW careers are over. I couldn’t be happier that they all stayed home and are at the UW.

Confusing to say the least. Next years class should help shed some light on the issue.

"Winning isn't everything, it's the only thing."
"Legends are made on the shores of Lake Washington"

by Lear Pilot on Jan 1, 2012 2:39 PM PST reply actions  

yeah, hard to know if this has just been an anomoly or a big warning sign

The thing that’s confusing to me is the idea this coaching staff wouldn’t understand the importance of building recruiting classes off the in-state talent first and supplementing as best they can with kids willing to leave California and Hawai’i, and picking off a few from Utah, Arizona, Oregon, Idaho & Montana.

I’m sure Sark feels like he has great connections in California & Hawai’i and great confidence he can poach some top guys there, but he’d be a complete idiot to not put supreme effort in corralling the top local guys. I don’t think he’s a complete idiot in that regard, and he certainly appeared to place great importance on the in-state guys from the moment he was hired, and he did very very well locally in the previous 2 classes.

That said, perception is reality – if there are certain local H.S. coaches that have an issue with Sark & staff, that needs to be addressed as best as possible. There’s bound to be tension from time to time when Sark doesn’t offer a kid that a coach thinks is worthy, and I’m sure some H.S. coaches are pushy and have outsized egos about trying to push their kids to certain schools, but that’s part of the deal in recruiting.

The thing to remember is, with every game now televised, cell phones, the internet, Skype, etc. it’s easier than ever for a kid to feel comfortable getting away from home for school. Family & friends can see every game and Skype & Facetime makes it easier to feel connected when away from home. That doesn’t mean staying close isn’t still the default, but I think it may not be realistic to think that the UW can keep pretty much every top local recruit home anymore like it used to be.

On the other hand, I think we are also seeing the longer-term impacts of a decade of crappy football and poor NFL production. The program is now back to being respectable, but for any recruit out there right now, their experience of Husky football is of a sucky team that has only recently started to go bowling again. There’s still a leap of faith for a recruit that Washington will return to be a conference title winner and compete for National Championships. And while the program is starting to put more than just a handful of kids into the NFL, I’m not sure that position groups other than QB’s, RB’s & LB’s were getting fully developed under this staff – and trust me, recruits have this pointed out to them in the recruiting process.

It may well be that this was just a really tough year for in-state recruiting in that many of the local guys really had little interest in the UW or had people close to them pushing them hard to go elsewhere. But it has to be a big warning flag for Sark.

by kirkd on Jan 1, 2012 4:17 PM PST up reply actions  

Very well put! Denial is a reality...

I know a certain current stud player who voiced his frustration in what he percieved as a big difference in how the staff valued Cali.kids over in-state studs…and this guy is no sour grapes type! He was just being real…and this is not hearsay! This stud who’s number I can’t quite recollect at the moment felt pretty strongly slighted about this issue…and he wasn’t complaining about a personal lack of love towards himself. So his words are all the more validated in my thinking…This perception is clearly an issue that better stop…it “may” have been dealt with two days ago? Here’s to hope!

by gliderdawg on Jan 1, 2012 8:14 PM PST up reply actions  

UW DC

The other blog has Utah dc Sitaki the person to watch

by Robert M on Jan 1, 2012 4:18 PM PST reply actions  

Rumored that Sarkisian has actually made Sitaki an offer.

The Dawgs could definitely do a lot worse, but the issue with Sitaki is that he’s similar to Holt – works for a defensive-minded head coach that may be the real architect of the defense’s success.

Sitaki is supposedly a pretty good recruiter. He’d certainly be an asset in recruiting the Polynesian players.

by Sundodger on Jan 1, 2012 5:16 PM PST up reply actions  

uw dc

Bob’s Seattle Times Blog

by Robert M on Jan 1, 2012 4:31 PM PST reply actions  

Yep

Read it there too…I think Sark has a pretty good idea of who he wants period and this will all go down pretty quickly.

UW Dawg Pound - SBN Seattle

by John Berkowitz on Jan 1, 2012 4:37 PM PST up reply actions  

Could be worse . . .

Penn State STILL doesn’t have a head coach, unbelievable.

"Winning isn't everything, it's the only thing."
"Legends are made on the shores of Lake Washington"

by Lear Pilot on Jan 1, 2012 5:50 PM PST up reply actions  

That's perfectly believable. That job is toxic right now.

A bunch of people would want it in 5 years, no one wants it right now.

by UW11Bowdown on Jan 1, 2012 8:46 PM PST up reply actions  

I do not believe that the job is toxic...

… no more so than Miami, Oregon, OSU or any other program actually facing demerits for their rules violations.

PSU’s big issue (in football) is instability in the AD office. That will settle and they will get a pretty good coach.

Damn, my eyeball tastes good.
@chrislandon

by Gekko Mojo on Jan 2, 2012 7:20 AM PST up reply actions  

Regarding Garnett

Here is a link to interview with Softy day after his announcement he basically states he wanted a “scenery change” get out of town to some place new and a little more sunshine and “broaden his horizons … see something different”

http://www.sportsradiokjr.com/player/?station=KJR-AM&program_name=podcast&program_id=softy.xml&mid=21675706

by lorenzothedog on Jan 1, 2012 5:15 PM PST reply actions  

I can't really find a fault with that type of thinking.

I think most of us wanted a good measure of independence when we got out of high school. Garnett has the oportunity to do that on somebody elses dime. I can see the point to that. I’ve been a HUGE Dawg fan all my life but honestly, being a sun lover, I would have a hard time passing up a scholorship from a school in the sun.

by Snostrebla on Jan 1, 2012 5:46 PM PST up reply actions  

except...

…it’s extremely likely that Garnett will find himself in a different part of the country anyway after college, either playing in the NFL or going on to Medical School. That’s a little bit of a red herring excuse IMO – a better recruiting job should have negated that thinking by Joshua. I’m guessing a bigger factor is just that he’s never really embraced the UW due to the program sucking for most of his formative years. And maybe, for whatever reason, his dad doesn’t feel as connected to his alma mater as some – his comment after Josh’s Michigan visit about how he wish he’d had an offer to go there was telling.

It’s not like Garnett is getting out of town to escape a bad family situation. With some kids you can totally understand a desire to get away to escape a tough situation, but I don’t believe that’s the case with Garnett.

by kirkd on Jan 1, 2012 6:16 PM PST up reply actions  

All good points...

…all I was trying to say was sometimes there’s more to the choice than just football. I do find it odd that deep down he had no interest in UW. Either Scott has issues with the UW or Josh looked at our current track record of developing NFL lineman. My gut tells me he’s headed to Stanford.

by Snostrebla on Jan 1, 2012 6:27 PM PST up reply actions  

Garnett

He just happens to think that there are much better academic and athletic options than Washington at this point.

Some kids want to be part of building something…others don’t…some just ant to get away.

UW Dawg Pound - SBN Seattle

by John Berkowitz on Jan 2, 2012 5:36 AM PST up reply actions  

UW DC

Sundoger read the same thing it’s Sitaki’s job if he wants it. UW could do alot worse I hope it’s not like holt and Sitaki does the job only time will tell. Any thoughts Mr. Berkowitz

by Robert M on Jan 1, 2012 5:51 PM PST reply actions  

My hope is, Sark plans to take over more of the nuts and bolts.

I suspect (without any real evidence) there was something in the Sarkisian-Holt relationship that didn’t really work as a management team. That Sark wanted certain things, and Holt wanted certain things, and they weren’t always the same things. And now Sark is looking to be much more in charge of the defense, every little piece of it, done his way. He’s looking to hire more of a true subordinate, instead of a take charge of it all guy.

by Hawnk on Jan 1, 2012 6:16 PM PST up reply actions  

I hope he'd be paired with a more experienced vet coach

I like poaching Sitake for the staff, but I’m not excited about him being “the guy” on the defensive staff for the same reasons Sundodger outlined above. He’s kind of “Nick Holt-lite” – he’s only worked for Kyle Whittingham, and the general impression is that Whittingham really runs the defense (much like it was presumed Carroll really ran the USC defense). And unlike Holt, Sitake has no other experience on his resume that would suggest he’s been a sought-after coach.

I like the fact he’s regarded as a good recruiter and great with the Poly guys, but it’s not like we’re doing badly with Poly players currently. If Sark brings him in, I hope he also brings in a vet like a Jim Heacock or Chuck Heater to help act as a mentor/sounding board to Sitake.

by kirkd on Jan 1, 2012 6:19 PM PST up reply actions  

It wont be Sitake...

He has no relationship with the UW or Sark.

UW Dawg Pound - SBN Seattle

by John Berkowitz on Jan 1, 2012 8:38 PM PST up reply actions  

not sure why that should matter

Hopefully Sark is looking for the best candidate he can get, and not just DC candidates he knows. Obviously you want them to be on the same page about how to coach and general philosophies, but if Sark is limiting his DC search to guys he has a direct relationship with, well, that’ll be a very short and incomplete search.

by kirkd on Jan 1, 2012 8:55 PM PST up reply actions  

strongly agree.

this is the time to use that new TV money to get the best available talent.

by HuskyInExile on Jan 2, 2012 12:10 AM PST up reply actions  

Sitake and Sark overlapped a year at BYU, I believe

… they have some mutual connections.

Damn, my eyeball tastes good.
@chrislandon

by Gekko Mojo on Jan 2, 2012 7:22 AM PST up reply actions  

I wouldn't bank my salary

on an unproven DC. I’d have to see a DC with 3 seasons of direct experience as DC. UW has good money to offer we need as close to a sure thing as possible.

We’ve got some good coaches coming into the league. The winners are the ones fielding good defenses.

by murchy on Jan 1, 2012 9:36 PM PST reply actions  

Sitake to stay

per Bob Condotta Utah officials say Kalani Sitake is not leaving. Justin Wilcox any thoughts on him

by Robert M on Jan 1, 2012 9:36 PM PST reply actions  

I like Wilcox

young…has excelled at multiple schools and positions and works with Peter Sirmon (LB Coach) could be a nice package deal.

by murchy on Jan 1, 2012 9:37 PM PST up reply actions  

Utah officials have a certain bias . . . :-)

UW has the ability to double or triple his salary, at a larger more prestigious school

by HuskyInExile on Jan 2, 2012 12:11 AM PST up reply actions  

Just need to pay more attention to local kids

Really I think UW just needs to pay attention to more local kids. Have scouts out to more games, make the rounds more, not think that UW is entitled to the local elites. Just my take. i also think picking up a couple tough nosed 2 or 3 star types is good for the program.

How about Tormey as a linbacker coach? He has a lot of local connections. He might not get a shot because he was on the TW staff but most always say he was a good guy and football mind.

by Fighting Husky on Jan 1, 2012 9:57 PM PST reply actions  

plus...

…a lot of rumblings from program insiders based off of Tormey’s recent stint at UW that he’s lost his fire and isn’t the coach he used to be.

by kirkd on Jan 2, 2012 12:31 PM PST up reply actions  

Ron Zook for DC - Any Chance???

Any chance we are looking at Zook? He was canned at Illinois recently, but I think is a pretty good coach and a defensive guy.

Probably a total shot in the dark, but it would be an interesting one…..

by Fighting Husky on Jan 1, 2012 10:03 PM PST reply actions  

Zook

He was the right guy at Florida and had good defenses at Illinois. Sometimes D1 coaches that fall flat on their face twice need to step back and go back to what made them successful.

by CgHawk360 on Jan 2, 2012 12:21 AM PST via mobile up reply actions  

If it makes you guys feel any better recruiting is still a crap shoot

Texas has had 4 top 10 recruiting classes the last 5 years, two in the top 5, and the lowest ranking was 16 according to scout and they went 8-5 this season. Player development is still far more important than how good a kid is at 18. I think you should have faith in the coaches to find guys that will be studs at 21 and 22 which is a lot more important in CFB than having the best group at 18. Heck Aaron Rodgers went to a JC. It’s disappointing to lose top in state guys but you can’t know how things will pan out in 3/4/5 years.

"If you want your dreams to come true, don't sleep in."

by kelly20210 on Jan 1, 2012 11:46 PM PST reply actions  

Truer words have never been written.

This is part of why football is so interesting; it is a complicated endeavour.

by HuskyInExile on Jan 2, 2012 12:14 AM PST up reply actions  

Sources tell me Wilcox is the new leader

Maybe even already agreed to a deal. And by sources, I mean some dude on facebook.

by B Money on Jan 2, 2012 1:38 AM PST via Android app reply actions  

Kim at Dawgman

Thinks that Justin Wilcox and Peter Sirmon could be added to the staff as soon as today.

UW Dawg Pound - SBN Seattle

by John Berkowitz on Jan 2, 2012 5:57 AM PST up reply actions  

this is a year old...sorry

not sure how much weight it carries anymore…

by bigdave967 on Jan 2, 2012 7:26 AM PST up reply actions  

Yeah - but Tennessee is in chaos and the natives want to eat Dooley's heart with some toast and butter.

… not the most stable situation in the world. UW isn’t perfect – but has to be more stable than that.

Damn, my eyeball tastes good.
@chrislandon

by Gekko Mojo on Jan 2, 2012 7:26 AM PST up reply actions  

Is he worth it?

Wilcox makes over $700,000 now – a background on him below
http://www.coachingsearch.com/home/225-candidates-for-washington-defensive-coordinator-position.html

His defenses at Tennessee do not seem to be that mind boggling in the Offensive challenged SEC Held ORE to 48 in 2010 – 8th in scoring D in SEC
http://web1.ncaa.org/football/exec/rankingSummary?org=694&year=2011&week=18

by lorenzothedog on Jan 2, 2012 7:29 AM PST up reply actions  

Is he worth it?

Wilcox makes over $700,000 now – a background on him below
http://www.coachingsearch.com/home/225-candidates-for-washington-defensive-coordinator-position.html

His defenses at Tennessee do not seem to be that mind boggling in the Offensive challenged SEC Held ORE to 48 in 2010 – 8th in scoring D in SEC
http://web1.ncaa.org/football/exec/rankingSummary?org=694&year=2011&week=18

by lorenzothedog on Jan 2, 2012 7:30 AM PST up reply actions  

yes

He put together outstanding defenses at Boise State with lesser talent. And at Tennessee he stepped into a situation where a lot of talent graduated prior to his arrival, and for a variety of reasons the cupboards weren’t well-stocked and he had to play a lot of 1st & 2nd year kids (sound familiar?) Only he did a lot better with his youthful squad than did Holt.

Tennessee fan reactions speak volumes, and I’ve yet to see any Vol fan say “Meh – not a big loss”. They’re pretty much all apoplectic at losing Wilcox & Sirmon.

by kirkd on Jan 2, 2012 12:34 PM PST up reply actions  

The nice thing about Wilcox

Go look at their recruits…top level talent….on DEFENSE. Wow, what a strange concept. Maybe he can bring one or two of those kids along for the ride. Who knows. Even so, if he can’t, hopefully he starts bringing that type of talent to the beaches of Montlake.

by bigdave967 on Jan 2, 2012 7:29 AM PST reply actions  

What this article lacked...

was that it focused on just the recruits to make its case.

And not the High School coaches around the state.

There are too many variables in just looking at the this year’s crop of kids. And didn’t we we bring pretty much all the “blue chips” last year headlined by K. Williams and ASJ?

I remember one of Sark’s first acts after the announcement of his hiring was to head out to a local HS game…see the local talent…build relations with the local coaches.

If this has been overlooked since then, the HS coaches would be among the first to know.

I like to hear what they’re thinking.

by ThaiDiamond on Jan 2, 2012 6:19 PM PST reply actions  

Who is fooling Who ???

“Zach Banner (Lakes)…”I have to give it a 12 – I saw what it was like to be a U-Dub Husky. I think that’s the one thing I had never seen before, never got the full feeling. For 48 hours, you’re part of the team; you can relate to everybody and talk with everybody and joke around. It was a good experience."

WTF…all other recruits thought they were losers!!!!

Don’t buy into the bull crap !!!

The Tunnel is Hallowed and Sacred Ground

by bigdawgdaddy999 on Jan 2, 2012 8:35 PM PST reply actions  

I'd rather have

a dozen two and three stars who wanted more than anything to be Huskies than the same number of four and five stars that came to UW because:

1. the coaches called daily and pumped their egos
2. they thought they were getting something for nothing
3. they were promised chrome helmets or anything else that probably would never come true

Bottom line: If these local kids don’t want to be Huskies, let’s find some kids that do!

by Saltherring on Jan 2, 2012 9:12 PM PST up reply actions   2 recs

I really do like this post.

Really. Couldn’t have said it any better.

by Hawnk on Jan 2, 2012 10:11 PM PST up reply actions  

The latest on Zach...

He favors Oklahoma.

UW Dawg Pound - SBN Seattle

by John Berkowitz on Jan 3, 2012 6:25 AM PST up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the UW Dawg Pound, an unofficial site for Washington Husky fans.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Learjet31a_1_jpg_small
Question of the Day:
T9odawgtest_small
A few Spring Game thoughts.
P1010006_small
Who Said College Basketball Recruiting was Supposed to be Clean?
Dubs_close_small
The Future Of Husky Basketball
Small
Updated: Arizona loses at home, Cal faceplants in style.
Dubs_close_small
PAC 12 Pickem Final Results
Dubs_close_small
UW Dawg Pound Tournament Challenge
Small
PAC 12 Tournament Tickets
Dubs_close_small
PAC 12 Pickem Results/Conference Tournament Schedule
Dubs_close_small
Tournament Challenge

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Managers

1959_huskies_small John Berkowitz

Dubs_small thecassino

Editors

W_logo_small kirkd

New_picture_small Gekko Mojo

Beastquakerwallpaper_small Ben Knibbe

Profpic_small JLee2025

Authors

Learjet31a_1_jpg_small Lear Pilot

Dubs_close_small CODawg

Coda_head_shot_250_small S_o_Smith

2721_small ToddWilliams206

P1010006_small Randall Floyd